Besides, how would you balance out sangheili vs humans? Would you just keep them out, alienating a player base? Would you divide the royale into two different game types for each race? That would require further resources that could be used elsewhere in the game.no its super easy its more the same thing you can do in call of dutty blackout all.
that you can choose if you wane play as a spartan or as Sanghelili and customaize it if there adding that option also to it.
that you play as spartan or sanghelili do's not matter since the both off then have the same health system and shield system the only thing is the look from it.
its the same as in halo 3 matchmaking there you can also play against elite's or spartans that system is good for it.
How about vehicles, would they be only human, or covenant ones added in too? Can a royale type game be balanced with vehicles like a banshee zipping around the field compared to a slower hornet or falcon? The Battle royale games work because that's what those game centered themselves on. COD got lucky and added theirs during the hype, compared to infinite which would release years later.both the UNSC and the covenant vehicles are good to use but the belance for each vehicle is good.
more like the ghost has no speed boost option then in a BR mode.
i go then more for a falcon option only with side guns but then with limit off ammo on it more like 200 rounds once's its emty you cant refull it more.
some vehicles are good with some chance's there have now in the main halo game and others are not good.
but still a mix off some vehicles from the UNSC and the covwnant are still good.
still to copy the stats from all the vehicles from the main halo game is not good to make a good fair BR game you need to make some twist's on the vehicles then
Don't need numbers to enjoy certain games. Played plenty of Reach custom games that were based off the DayZ game. Was great fun with only 16 people on different teams. Hell, if anything that at times felt more like a battle royale due to all the teams trying to converge on the red team base that had all the vehicles and goodies.for a BR game are the nummbers sometime's good if there are big.
its not a BR game that is be done in less then 10 min thats more a boring game then.
this has notting to do with score like in a BTB mode this is more about stay alive so long you can and try to win the match also.
Firstly, you are incorrect in stating that changes between Elites and Spartans is purely aesthetic. In fact, Elites have bigger hitboxes than Spartans due to their size. Readjusting the hitboxes would either A) require the redesign of Elites, making them look even weirder and worse or B) have issues with people saying that their shots did connect since it look like it hit the body, but the hitboxes don't fit the whole body. That is a whole issue on its own.
Secondly, vehicles would be hard to incorporate since it's a no respawn game and anyone can grab a banshee and wreck the whole area. You have three options: A) keep the vehicles as they are and -yoink!- some people off because they're constantly dying or need a vehicle to win, B) redesign or put a spin on the vehicles which could be potentially misleading and bring in a slew of issues, or C) remove them and cause issues in the sandbox since some weapons that are used mainly for the destruction of vehicles would be removed as well, and following those weapons would be removed their counter weapons (think of the sandbox as a sort of food web). So that is another dead end problem.
Finally DayZ isn't even a BTB game, so I don't know what you're talking about. And if you want to play a game mode where to you try to stay alive as long as possible then play Infection (and before you start to tell me Infection is different than BR, which I know it is, don't even bother trying to tell me that).
How do you fail to see that a BR has a lot of issues that would require the reconstruction of Halo? Those two examples were only two unfixable problems among many. Any way you choose to go it will collapse. It would benefit 343 more to not
make a BR since nothing happens if they don't (in fact they're praised
if they don't), but it's a near guarantee
that there will be brought in a slew of issues by the community if they do make a BR. So in conclusion, there is no reason for 343 to make a BR and it would benefit Halo Infinite and the series' image to not make one.
Give me one reason why they should. Also, if you're so bent on having a Halo BR, then go to a coding school and make one yourself.
Edit: Also, you said the best chance of a Halo BR is that it will be a separate game. I disagree, I think the best chance of it is that it won't exist, for the better.