wanna know why ?
how about you read the thread from beginning before posting ?
there are more than enough reasons to be against such high player counts in a major halo game.
Reasons (in no particular order)
Halo is a 4v4 game and anything larger is not Halo.
The maps would have to be bigger and I guess 343i can't do that.
The game has been small arena shooter forever and so it has to be forever.
If they make a bigger game no one will play the smaller game.
343i would have to devote resources to making this game, although right now they're developing MCC, Guardians, a web series and a tv series, starting on Halo 6, and maybe a movie.
You can't have that many players in a video game, even though it's been done on the original Xbox.
The weapon/vehicle balance would have to be recalculated, and 343i can't do that.
I don't like that kind of game, and you shouldn't, either.
If I'm on a team of 32 I won't stand out.
There's no way I can pay attention to what the other 31/63 players are doing, and there's no way I can get all those players to listen to me
A 128-player game could only be a slayer game. That's the only game 343i knows how to do.
People that want a large player count game just want a higher player count game and should just play BF, because they apparently haven't made it clear that they want a large player count Halo
How would it work? I can't figure it out so it must be impossible.
The matchmaking would have to be exactly like what we're used to, and it wouldn't work. Since 343i is incapable of developing a different matchmaking system for a different kind of game, there's no way it could happen.
A Halo game with more than 16 players will be the demise of the franchise. They'll never sell another game, book, comic, toy, t-shirt ever again
They did something different with Reach and H4 and look how badly they screwed those up. Trying anything different, therefore, will always result in disaster so they should just stick to what was never considered a disaster, which is what I happen to like anyway. BTW I never heard of halo2sucks.com.
There's more, but they're pretty much like these.