Forums / Games / Legacy Halo

Master Chief vs. Noble 6

OP Ivannov Maximof

  1. 1
  2. ...
  3. 29
  4. 30
  5. ...
  6. 31
No, Master Chief has much more combat experience and has near "perfect" genetics. (according to Dr. Halsey's screening) Although Noble 6 is very good, MC is better.
Have to agree here, but I think that Noble 6 also had the added benefit of better augmentations by then
Spartan IIIs are less powerful than Spartan IIs, making them worse. Anyways I think that it would be a very even battle but MC would win because of better augmentations, genetics, and luck.
Chief is the real badass bro while Noble 6 is the chill guy but neither got anything on the Rookie!
I do think it is conceivable that Six could beat the Chief in certain aspects. Stripped down without their armor, it could lead to a draw if Six plays his cards right. In armor, I think Six could win if he has the proper armor modules. But I think in most cases Chief would win.
Chief was called the green demon or demon by the prophets brutes elites grunts everything covenant. The prophets even had assignments for parts of there forces that they knew chief was fight to just find and stop and or kill him. No other spartan or unsc personnel had that. Chief even killed a covenant carrier by himself. Noble 6 needed Jorge and a team to help. 6 had a team. Yes John had Cortana, Johnson, sometimes the arbiter, marines with him but 90% of the time he was solo. He infiltrated high charity once convent and twice flood solo and won. Noble 6 never faced the flood. In halo 5 both cortana and halsey said john is the ultimate warrior it won't be easy to bring him in. Halsey even said it wont be easy to bring John in especially more now that blue team is with him. Cheif would take 6 to school and take out the trash. Marines that were separated for weeks months or years and lost all hope of being found and broken spirits when they saw john they rallied and fought even harder then when frist deployed because john was in a god like to the unsc. 6 unsc forces were like nice to have a spartan. With john unsc forces were like thats the chief we're saved. Hey look its the chief there in for it now. Noble was a child to john. Just the merrie presents of john on the battlefield unsc morale rose ten fold and convent morale was lost.
Czar Nicco wrote:
Where some of you are wrong is that the Spartan II's were also deployed in teams and Nobel 6 is also a Spartan II not a Spartan III. Master Chief is the only known suvivor of the II's he never had to face like 10 elites with different ranks and skill sets. Master Chief has faced only about 3 elites at once.
What about cheif solo except when he rescued the marine's in high charity going into the convent capital going to town fight both sides in the convent civil war and flood at same time then going back to save cortana when the flood and gravemind controlled it and living.
Mirages689 wrote:
I do think it is conceivable that Six could beat the Chief in certain aspects. Stripped down without their armor, it could lead to a draw if Six plays his cards right. In armor, I think Six could win if he has the proper armor modules. But I think in most cases Chief would win.
Chief was called the green demon or demon by the prophets brutes elites grunts everything covenant. The prophets even had assignments for parts of there forces that they knew chief was fight to just find and stop and or kill him. No other spartan or unsc personnel had that. Chief even killed a covenant carrier by himself. Noble 6 needed Jorge and a team to help. 6 had a team. Yes John had Cortana, Johnson, sometimes the arbiter, marines with him but 90% of the time he was solo. He infiltrated high charity once convent and twice flood solo and won. Noble 6 never faced the flood. In halo 5 both cortana and halsey said john is the ultimate warrior it won't be easy to bring him in. Halsey even said it wont be easy to bring John in especially more now that blue team is with him. Cheif would take 6 to school and take out the trash. Marines that were separated for weeks months or years and lost all hope of being found and broken spirits when they saw john they rallied and fought even harder then when frist deployed because john was in a god like to the unsc. 6 unsc forces were like nice to have a spartan. With john unsc forces were like thats the chief we're saved. Hey look its the chief there in for it now. Noble was a child to john. Just the merrie presents of john on the battlefield unsc morale rose ten fold and convent morale was lost.
Comparing the moral each Spartan gives to their forces is not a good way to measure who wins in a 1v1. Noble 6 is one of the most secretive Spartans to exist. Nobody knew of him outside the brass at ONI and the kids he trained with on Onyx. It's no wonder nobody has the same reaction to him as Chief.

Second, saying Chief fought the Flood, therefore he is the best Spartan is also not a helpful accomplishment in a 1v1. Chief said himself there are other Spartans better than himself, namely Fred-104. Now this doesn't mean Noble 6 isn't better because like I said, nobody knew he existed.

And when did Chief blow up a Covenant carrier by himself? Are you referring to the "to give the Covenant back their bomb" cutscene? Because of so, he didn't do that by himself. He used the Covenant equivalent of a nuke that was loaded onto Ciaro Station and was only able to destroy the ship because a Longsword blew a small whole in the hull of the carrier. If he had tried to detonate the bomb on the exterior of the ship, it most likely wouldn't have destroyed it because of the ship's shields. Granted this Isn't the same as having a team with him, but it definitely was the easier way to destroy a ship in comparison. Noble's mission was bigger than just destroying a carrier. They had to lure a corvette to the carrier first watch "required" more personnel to ensure its success. I'm sure Noble 6 could've done it himself because the actual part he was in the ship wasn't hard.

I also think you're underestimating the amount Cortana actually helps Chief. Chief wouldn't know half the time what he needed to do when it came to Forerunners and the Halo Rings if not for Cortana. She does all the processing and hacking and research Chief needs to get the job done. In addition to that, AI when inserted in MJOLNIR greatly enhances the users reflexes and timing which is seen when Cortana and Chief first meet and she allows him to make the exact correction at the right time to deflect a tracking missile during a compatibility test. If Noble 6 was given a Cortana, he'd be able to do the exact same stuff.

Now my argument to this topic, as has always been, is that Chief would lose the fight. Noble 6 is a trained headhunter, and not the kind who relies on a partner. His training and mission history set him up to become a lone wolf specialist completely reliant on only himself. This is different from Chief's training and mission history, which prior to Halo CE was mostly team based. Blue Team and all other Spartan-II teams were trained to trust each other and rely on each other's skills to get a job done. Sure they were also trained to complete tasks independently, but that wasn't their main focus. In The Flood novel, Chief was almost killed because of this when he first landed on Halo. An Elite snuck up on him and almost killed him because Chief was still in the mindset of having a team watch his flank for him.

I think that this dependency on teammates decreased as the games progressed, but it's still not something you can overlook. Noble 6 would have never made that mistake because it's not something he would've needed to account for. Granted both parties know it's going to be a 1v1, so this example doesn't entirely apply, but it shows the difference in the training. Noble 6 thrives on these types of situations, Chief doesn't.

TLDR: Noble 6s training and mission history is more centered around working alone therefore he would win against Chief who for most of his mission history has relied on a team.
I think master chief would he has a lot of experience fighting other Spartans beating Locke in halo 5 who worked with oni previously (I heard)
They're both strong.
I would loved master chief and noble 6 to team up. I believe they would have kicked the covenants butt with two hyper lethals running around
It'd be a draw.
Is "luck" the only factor that makes Master Chief superior to Noble 6?
Well no not in this case you have to understand that your comparing a spartan III headhunter to a Spartan II supersoilder it depends, if 6 had the element of surprise he MIGHT be able to assassinate cheif but in any other situation cheif would demolish 6. Edit: ALSO you have to take in that chheif has MUCH better armor and augmentations and Cortona who enhances his reflexes and reaction time and gives information about the surrounding area and enemy, also what weapons they have would be a key factor, also cheif's bones are like hard titainium i dout you run of the mill knife will do the trick. Winner: Cheif
Is "luck" the only factor that makes Master Chief superior to Noble 6?
Well no not in this case you have to understand that your comparing a spartan III headhunter to a Spartan II supersoilder it depends, if 6 had the element of surprise he MIGHT be able to assassinate cheif but in any other situation cheif would demolish 6. Edit: ALSO you have to take in that chheif has MUCH better armor and augmentations and Cortona who enhances his reflexes and reaction time and gives information about the surrounding area and enemy, also what weapons they have would be a key factor, also cheif's bones are like hard titainium i dout you run of the mill knife will do the trick. Winner: Cheif
Not necessary. Spartan-IIIs also had very similar augmentations to the IIs and even better ones depending on the generation. Noble 6 and Chief also wore the same generation of MJOLNIR armor so that is something to account for as well. And if this is a fight between Chief and Six, I don't think you can include Cortana in this fight since it gives Chief a clear edge. All this fight comes down to is training and the generation of their armor.
  1. 1
  2. ...
  3. 29
  4. 30
  5. ...
  6. 31